No VCDX Design Is Perfect • Chris Colotti's Blog

No VCDX Design Is Perfect


I wanted to quickly talk about something from my own personal VCDX experience that may help people a little bit that was in my head today.  There are very few IT Professionals that are NOT perfectionists.  It’s true, admit it, we are all very Type-A and with that comes a need to do everything as perfect as we possibly can.  True Type-A people take pride in the smallest of perfections.  That’s okay, it’s who you are, it’s who I am as well.  That being said I will say out loud right now to ease your personal pain that NO VCDX DESIGN IS PERFECT, this is because the only perfect design is the one that meets the customers requirements.  In fact, don’t tell yourself it has to be perfect.

Practice does not make perfect…..perfect practice makes perfect.  If you practice something 1000 times but you are practicing it wrong, they will always do it perfectly wrong.

Your VCDX Design Can Have Oddities

I will tell you as would my panelists, that my design was not perfect.  It had some odd things about it.  That did not make the design wrong though.  It met the customer’s requirements presented to me.  I was able to defend those design aspects mainly because the customer had some ODD requirements and constraints.  That also added to the list of risks by default of course.  The only perfect design is the one that meets all the requirements, constraints, and assumptions set forth by the customer.

Now, that being said, if you don’t understand the decision made that may indicate you were not really involved in the decisions.  It is also not a valid response to say “the customer said so”.  If you were truly involved in the design like I was, you would have knowledge and talking points to the discussions you directly had with the customer.  You can also explain how you maybe would have done it differently had the requirement not been so strange or odd.  Just be sure you are technically accurate in your reasoning why you’d do it differently.

Let’s face it, our customers don’t all have the same requirements, and you need to sometimes go outside any documented best practice to meet them.  This doe NOT make it a bad or incorrect design… long as you can defend your reasons with more that “That’s what the customer wanted”.  Talk about the discussions you had, why they felt they may not have wanted to follow your recommendations.  Give more details to the story to fill int he blanks.  It made for some really interesting conversation in my defense for sure!  It actually made it more fun of a process, I did not feel like I was defending anything.  Instead I felt like we were all having a spirited discussion about some interesting requirements I had to work with.

Check Also

The State Of VCDX Nearly A Decade Later – VMworld 2017

Yesterday I stopped by the VCDX town hall to catch up with some old friends …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: